The Boys' Black Noir Identity Twist Explained (2024)

Caution: spoilers ahead forThe Boys season 3

The Boys season 3 completely reframes Black Noir by revealing the tragic truth behindthe man - here's everything we learn in "Barbary Coast" and what it all means. SinceThe Boys premiered in 2019, Vought's Seven lineuphasfluctuated more thanBilly Butcher's accent. Though Homelander, Queen Maeve and Starlight remain present throughout, A-Train left then came back, Deep left then came back, and Translucent left then came back... in several pieces. Black Noir, however, offers the Seven a reliable presence. A shadowy ninjapossessing powers of strength, agility and durability, Black Noir is the very definition of "silent but deadly."

Despite him providingthe Seven's backbone,The Boys has revealedprecious few details about Black Noir's backstoryand identity.Season 2 confirmed Noir was a Black man underneath the mask, and also hinted towards some horrific facial injury. Meanwhile,The Boys Presents: Diabolical surprisinglyconfirmedNoir was Vought's most popular hero in the years immediately before Homelander debuted. Rather than get jealous about Madelyn Stillwell's patriotic newcomer, Black Noir actually helped Homelander on his unstoppable road to the top, explaining why these two supes areso tight inThe Boys.

Related:The Boys’ Dawn of the Seven Parody Takes Shots At… Rogue One?

Those scant factoids aside, Black Noir has cast an aura of total mystery acrossThe Boys... until now. As Billy Butcher continues his Soldier Boy investigation, Black Noir's untold history gradually unravels. Not only do lingering questions get answered, but Noir becomes an infinitely more tragic character with each and every scene.

Black Noir Was A Member Of Soldier Boy's Payback Team

The Boys' Black Noir Identity Twist Explained (1)

The Boys season 3's first Black Noir detail comes duringthe premiere episode,where Queen Maeve hands Butcher a stolen fileconcerningPayback.A photowithinshows the group'scentral trio of Jensen Ackles' Soldier Boy, Laurie Holden's Crimson Countess and a young, gun-loving Gunpowder, but standing second-from-left is the familiar, inconspicuous figure of pre-Seven Black Noir. Butcher thencements theconnection bysuggesting Maeve should look a little closer to home in Seven Tower for more information about Soldier Boy's death.The Boysalready teased Black Noir's Payback past in marketing material, but season 3 confirms exactly when and how he was a member.

In terms of which supe was strongest, Soldier Boyholds the edge over his masked colleague. Butcherbelieves the wartime hero was almost on-par with Homelander, whereas Black Noir is probably closer to Queen Maeve's power level. Regardless, fighting in the Payback crew evidently earned Noir a strong public following, as flashbacks reveal "Black Noir Dark Roast" coffee beans were a thingduring the 1980s (and used to smuggle cocaine into the US). In conversation with Stan Edgar, Noir also mentions taking on a more "central role" in Payback, which speaks to his soaring stock, and how he'll one day succeed Soldier Boy as Vought's top guy.

Black Noir's Age, Identity & Superhero Persona Explained

The Boys' Black Noir Identity Twist Explained (2)

InThe Boys' present day, Black Noir is renowned for never speakingand neverremoving his mask,but season 3's Nicaragua flashback explains where those habits came from. Talking privately with Stan Edgar, a helmet-free Noir says he wants to "lose the mask" and become a superhero with a face. His request is flatly denied because Edgar's market research shows the "silent ninja" gimmick is incredibly popular with young boys.Unveiling his true face andspeaking in public would, according to Vought, only ruinNoir's brand. This scene confirms Black Noir's enigmatic aura was - initially, at least - a marketing ploy.

Related: The Boys Finally Explains Its Best Supernatural Easter Egg

The Boys season 3 then adds a much darker note to Black Noir's history by revealing his early superhero career was hampered by racism. Silent ninjas might scorehighly in popularity polls, but Stan Edgar describes the notion of a Blackman in America's top superhero team as a "non-starter" forcertainareas ofthe USA in 1984. Black Noir's costume wasdesigned to cover up his skin color.

Underneath the mask, Noir comes across asa pretty regularsupe with regular supe worries,and is playedby Fritzy Klevans-Destine rather than usual actor Nathan Mitchell. Given his severe reputation inThe Boys, it's ironic that Black Noir had a great sense of humor back in 1984, semi-joking to Edgar about how he wears his maskwhile hailing cabs. Noir's bright, vocal, almost goofy personality is - by design - the exact opposite of his superhero reputation.

NowThe Boys has unveiled Black Noir's face, we can take a rough guess at his age. "Barbary Coast" doesn't state exactly when Noir was born, but the character looks (and bearing in mind he's already an established hero by this point) in his early-mid 20s. Payback's Nicaragua mission happened in 1984, so Noir would be in his 60scomeThe Boys season 3's present day. Compound-V subjects generally age slower than normal folk, of course, so it's possible Black Noir has been around even longer than that.

Why Black Noir Wears A Mask & Never Talks In The Boys

The Boys' Black Noir Identity Twist Explained (3)

Two big questions followed Black NoirthroughoutThe Boys seasons 1 & 2 - why does he wear a mask, and why doesn't he talk?The Boys season 3's "Barbary Coast" satisfies on both accounts... and it's all thanks to Payback's gross incompetence. Payback was drafted into Grace Mallory's Nicaragua operation as atrial for supesjoining the US military, but the experiment went as wrong as you'd expect. Ignoring a direct order from Stan Edgar, Swatto couldn't resist stretching his insect wings, and the sight of a costumed idiot hovering above the treesalerted enemy soldiers tothe location of Mallory's camp. Had they been even remotely useful, Vought's Payback team could've defeated these soldiers with ease. Instead, Crimson Countess struggled to tell the difference between friend and foe,while Gunpowder got so riled up having a big gun in his hands, he mowed down anything that moved.

Related:Why The Boys Season 3 Looks So Different

A potentcombination of friendly fire and rockets left the entire camp a flaming mess, and Black Noirgot caught directly in the mayhem. When Mallory discovers him, the left side of Noir's face is completely burned - the skin bubbling hot, left eye loose in its socket, and large chunks of hair scorched. These injuries explain the glimpse ofburnedface viewers spotted in The Boys season 2.Looking directly at Mallory, Noir reaches desperately for his fallen mask, hinting that he'll spent the next 40 years willingly covering up his face to hide the damage. The Boys'Payback tragedy pays off Stan Edgar's ominous prediction that Black Noir would one day be "begging" for his mask back.

As Noir gurgles toward Mallory, audiences can also assume this is how the supe lost his ability to talk. There's a bitter irony in how Black Noirsuffered considerably more injuries than his Payback colleagues, but was actually one of the group'stwo competent members (Soldier Boy himself being the other). During the attack, Noir was shown fending off attackers with a blade, deftly protecting Stan Edgar from harm while the other supes screwed up spectacularly.

How The Boys Season 3 Explains Black Noir'sPersonality

The Boys' Black Noir Identity Twist Explained (4)

Filling the gaps, it seems Vought patched up Black Noir and readied their man for a post-Payback solo career, which he took to like Justin Timberlake after N*Sync.The Boys season 3's Nicaragua flashback mightalso explain why Noir is such a loyal soldier for Vought in the present day. The so-called "Silent Knight" clearly has Stan Edgar's ear, with the pair's shared history dating back four whole decades. Black Noir might've even been Edgar's pet project in the same way Madelyn Stillwell oversaw Homelander. Either way, Noir's long-standing Edgar association neatly accounts forwhyhe never questions orders and always does Vought's bidding with perfect, clinical obidence.

ThoughThe Boys season 3 doesn't spend long with young Noir, he's presented as a more reasonable, down-to-earth supe - a far cry from egotistical types like Soldier Boy and Homelander, or reckless types like A-Train and Crimson Countess. That rational mindset might explain the flickers of kindness Noir has demonstrated previously inThe Boys-handing a youngchild a cuddly toy during the Syria mission, for example. He's still awful, obviously,but notquite as awful as everyone else, and season 3's flashback provides more context as to why Black Noir's moral compass points in the direction it does.

Join Amazon Prime - Watch Thousands of Movies & TV Shows Anytime

Start Free Trial Now

More: Butcher’s Powers In The Boys May Recreate A Homelander Comic Twist

The Boys continues Friday on Prime Video.

The Boys' Black Noir Identity Twist Explained (2024)

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Virgilio Hermann JD

Last Updated:

Views: 6623

Rating: 4 / 5 (41 voted)

Reviews: 88% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Virgilio Hermann JD

Birthday: 1997-12-21

Address: 6946 Schoen Cove, Sipesshire, MO 55944

Phone: +3763365785260

Job: Accounting Engineer

Hobby: Web surfing, Rafting, Dowsing, Stand-up comedy, Ghost hunting, Swimming, Amateur radio

Introduction: My name is Virgilio Hermann JD, I am a fine, gifted, beautiful, encouraging, kind, talented, zealous person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.