Vanilla Sugar Recipe (4 Easy Ways!) (2024)

Looking for a new secret weapon to add to your culinary arsenal? You’re in luck! Today I’m going to show you how to make vanilla sugar 4 different ways so you can give any of your favorite coffee, co*cktail, or baking recipes an easy glow-up. Best of all, you only need 2 ingredients and about 5 minutes of active kitchen time to make it. As a bonus, I’ve also included a free printable for my custom vanilla sugar labels!

Why You’ll Love This Homemade Vanilla Sugar Recipe

• Quick & Easy - All you need are 2 ingredients and a few minutes of active time to make a batch. And, depending on the method you use, once it’s made, you can keep replenishing the sugar for several months so you have a constant supply!
• Accessible - My favorite method for making vanilla sugar uses a food processor and whole vanilla bean pods. But I know that not everyone has access to either the expensive equipment or spendy vanilla beans. Because of this, I’ve figured out how to make vanilla sugar with vanilla extract, paste, powder, AND pods so everyone can get in on the fun!
• All-Purpose - In nearly every recipe that calls for sugar, you can swap in an equal amount of this enchanting vanilla bean sugar for a little extra flair. It's an incredibly versatile ingredient!

Recipe Ingredients

As promised, you only need 2 ingredients to make this recipe for vanilla sugar. I’d bet you can guess what they are, but as always, there's nuance:

• Granulated Sugar - Plain white sugar is neutral in flavor, meaning the complexity of vanilla can truly shine. You can also use raw cane sugar, or any other sugar/sugar-substitute of your choosing from the “Optional Variations” section below.
• Vanilla - When it comes to adding vanilla flavor, there are LOTS of options:
  • Beans/Pods - Using whole vanilla pods and their seeds will give you the most potent vanilla flavor while keeping your sugar a crisp white color. Plus, you’ll see those stunning vanilla bean flecks that give this sugar a sort of “artisan” feel. This is - in my opinion - the best option!
  • Powder -Ground vanilla beans, often referred to as vanilla bean powder, are a great option if you want the visual effect of the vanilla seeds, but don’t want to deal with the whole pod. The caveat is that, like other spices, pre-ground vanilla will lose potency faster than whole vanilla, so keep this in mind if you decide to purchase it. You can use 1 teaspoon of ground vanilla in place of the 2 vanilla beans called for in this recipe. Don’t get ground vanilla beans confused with vanilla powder, which is a white, powdery mixture of vanilla extractives and dextrose that I don’t recommend using here.
  • Paste - I LOVE vanilla paste because it has the convenience and similar price-point of vanilla extract, but also has those vanilla specks I find so charming. This is my second-favorite form of vanilla to use in this recipe. That said, it will give your sugar a light golden tint, and because it adds moisture to the sugar, there’s additional time required to let the sugar dry out.
  • Extract - Vanilla extract, like paste, will add both color and moisture to your sugar, so keep this in mind. If you go with this option, make sure to use pure vanilla extract, NOT vanillin (artificial vanilla flavor). You have choices here too! Bourbon vanilla extract has a rich, oaky undertone, whereas “regular” vanilla extract is made with neutral-flavored vodka.

How to Make Vanilla Sugar — 4 Easy Ways

Option 1: With Whole Vanilla Beans (Preferred)

Step 1: Blitz. In a food processor fitted with the steel blade attachment, combine granulated sugar with the vanilla bean seeds scraped from two whole pods. (Use a sharp knife to cut them in half before removing the seeds, and set the spent pods aside for step 2.) Process until the vanilla is fully and evenly incorporated into the sugar.

Step 2: Store in an airtight container, adding the now-empty pods (cut in half if needed) before covering with a lid. For the best, most potent flavor, set aside for at least 2 weeks before using.

Option 2: With Vanilla Bean Paste or Vanilla Extract

Step 1: Blitz. In a food processor fitted with the steel blade attachment, combine granulated sugar with vanilla bean paste or vanilla extract. Process until the vanilla is fully and evenly incorporated into the sugar. Making vanilla sugar with extract or paste means the sugar will get a bit clumpy due to the moisture — this is normal.

Step 2: Dry. Spread the sugar out in a thin, even layer on a baking sheet. Add a piece of parchment paper for easy cleanup if preferred. Let it dry for several hours or overnight; the sugar will harden once dry. The bonus here is that your kitchen will smell like a warm vanilla sugar candle!

Step 3: Blitz & Store. Use the tip of a flat spatula to break the sugar into small pieces. Transfer it back to the food processor and process until all clumps are gone and the mixture has returned to the texture of standard granulated sugar. Store in an airtight container. Feel free to use immediately.

Option 3 (Equipment-Free): With Ground Vanilla

Don’t have a food processor? Not to worry. You still have options!

Step 1: Mix sugar with ground vanilla beans in a container until well-combined. You can use this immediately, but again, it will taste best if you cover it and let it sit for at least 2 weeks so the sugar has time to take on more of the vanilla flavor.

Option 4 (Equipment-Free): With Whole Vanilla Beans or Spent Vanilla Pods

Wondering how to make vanilla sugar quickly? This is as quick and easy as it gets. For an simple, albeit slightly less potent, vanilla flavored sugar:

Step 1: Add whole, fresh vanilla beans or the (dry) spent pods of two vanilla beans that were used for another purpose (like homemadevanilla ice cream) directly to granulated sugar in an airtight container. (See “Recipe Tips” below for notes on using spent pods.)

Step 3: Replenish the container with fresh sugar as you use it.

Optional Variations & Dietary Adaptations

• Sugar-Free Vanilla Sugar - Substitute granulated sugar with an equal amount of your favorite granulated sugar alternative, such asmonk fruitorerythritol.
• Coconut Vanilla Sugar -Similar to the variation above, you're welcome to usecoconut sugar​ in place of granulated sugar for an option that's refined sugar-free.
• Vanilla Powdered Sugar - Follow this recipe using the first food processor method above, but add an additional tablespoon of corn starch per cup of sugar and process until the sugar is fine and powdery. You can also simply use powdered (confectioner’s) sugar instead of granulated sugar, and process just until the vanilla bean seeds are incorporated. For this method, I would only recommend using whole vanilla beans or ground vanilla bean powder, since the moisture from vanilla extract or paste would likely throw off the consistency of the powdered sugar.
• Vanilla Cinnamon Sugar - When making your vanilla sugar, add anywhere from 2 to 4 tablespoons of ground cinnamon per cup of granulated sugar, depending on how much cinnamon flavor you want!
• Vanilla Brown Sugar - Start with brown sugar instead of granulated sugar, or add 1 ½ teaspoons of molasses per cup of granulated sugar along with the vanilla. Process until both the molasses and vanilla are fully incorporated, using a rubber spatula to scrape down your food processor as needed. As with the powdered sugar variation, I don’t recommend using vanilla extract or paste for this option since brown sugar already has extra moisture.

Recipe Tips

• Some people like to blend up the whole vanilla pod with the seeds and sugar. While you’re welcome to do this, I prefer just adding the empty pod to the sugar at the end so you don’t have to worry about it blending in completely, since the pod can be a bit "tough".
• If you use spent vanilla pods from another recipe where they were combined with something wet (like ice cream or custard), make sure you give them time to dry out completely first. I wouldn’t recommend using spent pods that were in contact with another strong flavor (e.g. chocolate pudding), unless you don’t mind another layer of flavor in your sugar.
• Make use of your appliances! I don't recommend using just elbow grease to mix the sugar with fresh vanilla seeds, vanilla paste, or vanilla extract, since the moisture makes it hard to mix evenly. A food processor works better and makes the job easier. A blender would likely work as well!
• For a small batch, you can also use a clean coffee grinder or spice grinder to mix your vanilla sugar.
• If you find vanilla sugar clumps in your container after storing, just give the sugar a quick stir with a spoon to smooth it out again. This is more likely to happen if you add the vanilla pod to your sugar before letting it dry out, since the pod retains a bit of moisture.
• Gift it! Homemade vanilla sugar can make a great gift; all you need to do is put it in a niceglass jarand add a cute label. I’ve made custom labels you can print out for this very reason!

Get your free vanilla sugar labels here!

How To Use Vanilla Sugar

Vanilla sugar makes everything it touches feel a little extra special. While it can be used in a 1:1 ratio with regular sugar for nearly any recipe, here are some of my favorite ideas to get you started:

• Coffee Glow-Up: I love using vanilla sugar to make my morning lattes! You can also use it in the flavoredsimple syrupsfor mylavender iced coffeeandmint iced coffee.
• Whipped Cream: Sweeten homemade whipped cream with vanilla sugar instead of plain sugar to add a little extra flavor to your desserts. For whipped cream recipes that call for powdered sugar (like mydairy free whipped creamorchocolate whipped cream), try using vanilla powdered sugar (listed under the “Optional Variations” heading in this post).
• co*cktail Rims: If you have a favorite co*cktail that calls for a sugar rim, use vanilla sugar! It would be a great addition to this sweet-tartraspberry limoncello co*cktail.
• Vanilla Sugar for Baking: I have a number of recipes with vanilla sugar for you to try! I use it in my tangykumquat cake,vanilla bean scones,vanilla bean biscotti,vanilla ruffle cakes, and funfetti cake. It works especially well in recipes with lighter flavors where the vanilla can really shine.

Recipe FAQs

More Ways to Use Vanilla Sugar

Raise the bar on your baking - make any of these recipes with vanilla sugar in place of standard granulated sugar for even more deliciousness!

Homemade Vanilla Sugar

Learn how to make vanilla sugar at home with any form of vanilla you have on hand. My easy vanilla sugar DIY recipe includes 4 different methods using your choice of vanilla beans, vanilla extract, or vanilla paste. Plus, download and print a set of my free custom labels to make your jars of vanilla sugar look like they came from a specialty store!

Notes